Reservation
(310) 510-0060
Visit Us
114 Sumner Ave Avalon, CA 90704 United States
Hello dear
Welcome To Original Antonio's Pizzeria
At Original Antonio's Pizzeria, we embrace the essence of traditional pizza-making, serving up delectable slices that capture the heart of Avalon, Catalina Island. Located conveniently on Sumner Ave, our pizzeria offers a cozy, cafe-like atmosphere, perfect for families and groups. Guests rave about our flavorful pepperoni pizza, made with fresh ingredients and served with warm hospitality. With a speedy takeout window, outdoor seating, and a selection of refreshing beverages, including beer and wine, we cater to every craving. Whether you're here for a quick lunch or a relaxed dinner, our charming spot is a must-visit when exploring Catalina!
About
Original Antonio's Pizzeria
Welcome to Original Antonio's Pizzeria, a culinary gem nestled in the heart of Avalon, Catalina Island. This delightful eatery offers an array of mouthwatering pizzas and sandwiches that are sure to satisfy your cravings, whether you’re grabbing a quick bite or enjoying a leisurely meal with family and friends.
Located at 114 Sumner Ave, just a stone's throw from the vibrant bustle of the island, Original Antonio's Pizzeria is renowned for its casual, yet classy ambiance. The pizzeria is perfect for lunch or dinner, boasting a cozy interior that has more of a café feel, complete with patio seating for those who crave the fresh island air.
What sets Original Antonio's apart? Let’s take a deeper dive:
- Flavorful Offerings: Guests rave about the pepperoni pizza, lauded for its incredible flavor and freshness. With New York-style slices that are both generously sized and fairly priced, you can expect to find comfort in every bite. Whether dining in or opting for the busy take-out window, you’re in for a treat!
- Family-Friendly Vibe: This pizzeria is not just a meal stop; it's an experience! Families flock here to enjoy hearty meals together, and kids will find delight in the quirky decor and lively atmosphere. One visitor even noted a hilariously surprising bathroom sign that will surely make your little ones giggle!
- Convenience Meets Quality: Beyond delicious eats, Original Antonio's seamlessly hangs its hat on utilities like outdoor seating, Wi-Fi, and bike parking; ideal for the active, on-the-go visitor. With options for takeout, reservations, and catering, this pizzeria accommodates different needs with ease.
- Community Favorite: Many patrons return time and again, calling Original Antonio's a "must-visit" when in Catalina. Local reviews speak volumes of its consistent quality, fast service, and friendly staff, ensuring that you feel right at home.
If you’re indulging in a Catalina Island adventure, make it a point to stop by Original Antonio's Pizzeria. As one review put it perfectly: "By far, this is some of the best pizza the island has to offer." So grab your friends, enjoy a refreshing beer or wine only from their selection, and make unforgettable memories over delicious slices.
For more information, feel free to call (310) 510-0060 or stop by and see for yourself why everyone’s talking about Original Antonio's Pizzeria!
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ Visited on a cruise port day. My sister recommended this pizza spot as she has visited many times before. We ordered at the outside window and did self seating in the patio area. The pizza came out in about 10 minutes. Everyone one in my party was very impressed with the pepperoni pizza! This is must try place when in Catalina! ”
“ We were on the island for an overnight family stay. My kids really wanted pizza for dinner and this was conveniently across from our hotel; The Atwater. The Pizzeria is warm and cozy inside... more of a cafe feel than restaurant. They serve bottled beer/wines and canned alcohol. Some fountain drinks... The food was as expected for a pizzeria. Pricing was fair. The pizza take out window was extremely busy our entire visit. Overall a great dinner experience. My son (who is 8yrs old) was laughing and red in the face after returning to the table after visiting the bathroom to the "RIGHT" - - you will understand when/if you visit this business :) the photos on the wall are one to shock your children haha! ”
“ A must visit place! Everything is delicious and fresh. Crisp soda with the good ice. Amazing service ”
“ Original Antonio's Pizzeria is a hole in the wall (even got the take-out window in the wall for it!), but they have absolutely come in clutch for getting a toddler a big ol' slice of pizza at the drop of a hat. It's your typical greasy New York slice, but can't deny their appeal. Thanks again! ”
“ When visiting Catalina Island in Avalon California, and craving pizza, this is definitely a must stop. By far, this is some of the best pizza the island has to offer. The pizza is always flavorful and great tasting. It's sold by the slice or as a whole. The slices are well proportioned and priced accordingly. The ingredients are fresh and the pizza is delivered at the perfect temperature. If you've never visited Catalina Island in Avalon California, I encourage you do. It's a relatively We're small but quaint island and is a great day trip either solo or with a family. I've also included videos/photos of various locations around the island. ”
